Pizza Quest Globe

DiNapoli Fire Roasted Tomato Pizza Sauce

Written By Brad English
Wednesday, 09 January 2013 Written Recipes

It starts with a good dough. I didn’t say a round dough!

The hardest part of making a great pizza at home is making and baking a great pizza dough.  I found Peter Reinhart because this otherwise simple task eluded me in my home pizza making endeavors for so long.  I now make what I consider to be a decent dough, or doughs as I keep trying to chase that perfect pizza experience here at home with my family.

The next thing you have to master after you have a good dough is your tomato sauce.  Once again, I credit Peter with my favorite sauce.  His Crushed Tomato Sauce recipe is simple and delicious.  It’s perfectly balanced.  You make it cold and let it cook up right on the pizza.   Check out the recipe *HERE if you haven’t tried it.  I make it so often, I don’t look at the recipe anymore.  I simply add the ingredients by feel – a pinch of this and a couple pinches of that.


The fire roasting adds an amazing depth of flavor to these quality California tomatoes. I would call this sauce not only delicious, but interesting.

I met Rob Dinapoli for the first time at the Pizza Expo last year before he became one of our sponsors. I was talking to a friend of his and noticed a can of their Fire-Roasted Tomatoes.  The artwork on the can caught my eye.  I said to him that those would make an interesting pizza sauce.  His friend went on about how he uses it all the time for pastas and I wish I had taken some notes.  When the show was over, Rob gave me his last #10 can to take home and try.


I finally got around to trying these out and my hunch was right!  Here’s what I came up with for my version of a Fire-Roasted Tomato Sauce.  I give credit to Peter’s original Crushed Tomato Sauce that inspired where I wanted to go with this.  I think you will love the results.



DiNapoli Fire-Roasted Tomato Sauce:

Olive Oil

Chopped Garlic  (2 or 3 Large Cloves)

Chopped Onions  (about 1/4 of an Onion)

DiNapoli Roasted Tomatoes (14.5 Oz Can)

Dried Basil

Dried Oregano

Kosher Salt

Ground Pepper


To Do:


I threw a lot of garlic and onions into this sauce.

Chop up some garlic.  I used a good amount about 2-3 Large Cloves for a small batch of this sauce.  Chop up the onion.  I chopped mine into somewhat larger pieces to allow them to remain present in the sauce after they cooked down.  I wanted to give this sauce a chunkier texture.  The tomatoes are diced and also have that chunkiness to them.  As you will see it all cooks down and spreads nicely on the dough, but when you scoop it out of the pot and taste it, you can almost chew it!


Saute the Garlic and Onions in the Olive Oil until translucent.  *I took this a little further to where they began to brown and almost char.  I felt like this would add to the texture and flavor of this sauce and accent the fire-roasting of the tomatoes even more.


I gave these a little hand crushing, or squeezing in a bowl before adding to the pan.

Add the tomatoes and juice from the can.


Add a good pinch of the dried Basil and Oregano (about 1/2 – 1 teaspoon each to start)


Add a pinch of salt and freshly ground pepper, to your taste.


*I love the concept of adding a “pinch”!  It is different for everyone.  We could do a study and have 100 people add a pinch of salt and do some math and come up with what the average pinch measurement is.  Instead, the pinch allows you to make it your own and more importantly it urges you to cook by feeling or instinct.  Just a thought…


Simmer the sauce and add in the herbs and seasoning.

Bring the mixture to boil and then let it simmer for a while (probably 10-15 minutes) to allow it to reduce a little and come together.


After it cooled down a bit I took my first taste.  As I mentioned above the sauce was almost chewable.  The thing that struck me was that this sauce was not only chewy, but almost meaty in flavor.   I was standing there at the stove tasting the sauce to see if it needed anything and I my first thoughts were about this being a meat sauce.  It was delicious!  It had a roasty-meaty flavor at the base and finished with a salty sweetness.









Can this sauce be canned?

Add Comment

Pizza Quest Info


Vision Statement

Pizza Quest is a site dedicated to the exploration of artisanship in all forms, wherever we find it, but especially through the literal and metaphorical image of pizza. As we share our own quest for the perfect pizza we invite all of you to join us and share your journeys too. We have discovered that you never know what engaging roads and side paths will reveal themselves on this quest, but we do know that there are many kindred spirits out there, passionate artisans, doing all sorts of amazing things. These are the stories we want to discover, and we invite you to jump on the proverbial bus and join us on this, our never ending pizza quest.

Peter’s Books

American Pie
Artisan Breads Every Day
The Bread Bakers Apprentice
Brother Junipers Bread Book
Crust and Crumb
Whole Grain Breads

...and other books by Peter Reinhart, available on