Pesto Genovese


Note to readers: This is an excerpt from my book, American Pie: My Search for the Perfect Pizza (Ten Speed Press). This recipe is one of my most requested and I think it rivals any pesto recipe I've seen or tried anywhere. Let me know what you think when you try it.

When I first discovered pesto about 35 years ago I thought the heavens had opened and revealed a very special secret. It was so new to Americans then, and now it’s so familiar and has been overused in so many ways that it runs the risk of being a culinary cliché. But throughout my travels in Liguria and Genoa (and thus the term Genovese), where it has been a staple for centuries, nobody seems to tire of it and my passion for it was born anew. The problem with much of the pesto of recent memory in this country is its lack of brightness--not just in color but brightness as a flavor tone. That's where the lemon juice makes the difference in the recipe below--it's my secret ingredient.

My favorite pesto memory in the United States was at the legendary Caffe Sport in North Beach during its glory years in the 1970’s when Tony Latona was alive, roaming back and forth between the kitchen and the dining room. His pesto was bright green, the basil flavor exploded in my mouth, carried by the cheese and pine nut base notes. A lot of restaurant pesto now is a dull green, thick and pasty, the flavors locked up, trapped in the cheese. It had been a long time since pesto sent me into ecstasy but when it was served to us at Ristorante da Vittorio in the town of Recco over some toothsome troffie pasta, I felt as though

time had compressed and I was discovering it anew, like my first time at Caffe Sport.


The following recipe can be baked directly on top of focaccia or pizza, or drizzled over it after it comes out of the oven (my preferred way to use it, just as you would over pasta). You can also use over any kind of pasta and also with grilled chicken. At home, we often make bruschetta with pesto and freshly diced heirloom tomatoes and just a sprinkle of coarse sea salt. Or, when no one's looking, just slather the pesto on some fresh bread and have at it!



2 cups (tightly packed)  fresh basil leaves, washed thoroughly

8 cloves fresh garlic, minced, not pressed, lightly sauteed in a tablespoon of olive oil (to take out the "hotness")

1 cup extra virgin olive oil

1 1/2 tablespoons  fresh lemon juice

3/4 cup freshly grated parmesan, romano, or grana padana cheese (do not use pre-grated, box cheese)

1 cup pine nuts, lightly toasted

salt and pepper to taste

Place all the ingredients in a food processor (not a blender) and process for about 30 seconds, or until smooth. Add more olive oil if it is too thick; add more grated cheese if it is too thin (lately, I've been using Bel Gioioso Grana for my dry aged cheese needs--nice flavor and acidity). Add salt and pepper to taste, but the cheese provides enough salt for most people, and pepper is optional.

An option is to hold back half of the toasted pine nuts and grated cheese and fold them into the pesto after it has been processed. This adds another layer of texture--little flavor bursts of toasted nuts and salty cheese. (Note: you can substitute toasted walnuts for the pine nuts if you prefer)

Keep the pesto in a tightly covered container in the refrigerator. It will be good for up to a week. If the top surface darkens, this is just oxidation--simply stir it back in--it should be bright green underneath, However, if you freeze it, it will remain bright green until you thaw it, at which time it will darken throughout (more oxidation). You can still use it but it won't be as vibrant looking (but dark pesto is better than no pesto at all--perhaps stir in a little lemon juice). You can also replace some of the fresh basil with other fresh green herbs, such as parsley or arugula or a very small amount of stronger herbs such as fresh oregano or marjoram.  Roasted red peppers can also be substituted, to taste.




#1 shankopotomus 2011-01-12 16:20
Solid pesto recipe. If you want to add a little food science to it: in a mortar, pound one vitamin c tablet into complete powder. Add this to the mix. Vitamin C is a powerful antioxidant and will preserve the color for a long time. It also adds some tartness like lemon juice. Lemon juice is also a good source of vitamin C and citric acid (a good antioxidant). You just need to add a lot to get the same effect.

I make the whole thing in the mortar. It's chunkier and kind of rustic and builds muscle.

Great website
#2 Peter Reinhart 2011-01-12 20:48
Yes, a mortar and pestle is the real deal. Pesto actually means "pounded" and thus the term "pestle" for the pounding tool. I use the food processor simply because it's faster, but there's nothing like the primalness of pounding and smelling those aromas as they are volatized and released.
That's a great tip on the Vitamin C. What strength pill do you use and is it ascorbic acid Vitamin C that you use?
#3 Yehuda 2011-01-12 23:27
yum sounds great! Isn't 8 cloves too much though? I usually use one or two, more than that is usually too strong. Is the sauteing the trick? Also can this be done with a hand blender?
btw love the site!
#4 shankopotomus 2011-01-13 08:25
1000 mg Ascorbic acid. Make sure it's only vitamin C. No added rose hips or b complex. You will get some very bad flavors from other vitamins. You can also get pure from some places on line. Le Sanctuaire has a liquid form.
#5 Peter Reinhart 2011-01-13 09:05
As for the garlic, yes, lightly sauteing it in olive oil is my secret trick for how to get more garlic in without burning our mouths or offending our loved ones. It takes the "burn" out. But really, just a quick. light saute, not for browning, just for about thirty seconds so you get max flavor without the burn. Try it and let us know what you think.
#6 Yehuda 2011-01-19 10:42
I just made the pesto. Amazing! I even ended up adding in a clove of fresh garlic cause i wanted a bit of an extra garlic kick. (I might of sauted it a drop too long.) Wife and i ate it over spaghetti with a bit of melted mozz and roasted cherry tomatoes. What a great supper! Thanks peter
#7 Rob 2011-01-20 10:24
Anyone know if this will still work well without Pine Nuts (I'm allergic) or a good substitute for them?
#8 Brio 2011-01-20 13:55
I have bben making Pesto from my home grown basil for years. I am always disappointed when the pesto darkens from oxidation. I will try the vitamin C next time. Anyone else have any suggestions as how to deal with this issue?
#9 Tina 2011-08-24 19:12
@ Rob, I just made pesto without pine nuts and little more of the grated cheese. It came out pretty good. I used as topping on Mr. Reinhart's neo-neapolitan dough. Delicious! Thanks for the recipes Mr. Reinhart!
#10 JMart 2011-09-25 15:44
Caffe Sport has been a favorite of mine since 1980. My Italian prof at Santa Clara, Giovanni Tempesta, recommended the place and I have had many unbelievable meals with friends, family and perfect strangers. The pesto is the best I have had and I've been to Italy 3x. Now, two of my kids are in college in the City and the saga continues. The son is running it differently but still some of the same guys there since back in the 80's. Go to the The Sport! It beats 90% of the places in North Beach hands down.

Add comment

Security code


Login Form

Who's Online

We have 37 guests online

Peter's Books

American Pie Artisan Breads Every Day Bread Baker's Apprentice Brother Juniper's Bread Book Crust and Crumb Whole Grain Breads

… and other books by Peter Reinhart, available on